Cause and Effect: The Missing Link
Within the history of human thought the notion of cause and effect has ever been regarded as an established reality. We hold that every occurrence in the universe is the outcome of some cause, and that every cause gives birth to a fresh occurrence. From the concerns of our everyday life to the frontiers of scientific research, our thinking revolves around this very principle. We say that fire burns wood, that glass shatters under the blow of a stone, and that rain irrigates the earth. Yet have we ever reflected upon that which we call cause and effect? Is there, in truth, a necessary bond between the two which we have actually discovered, or do we simply behold two events arising together or one after the other, and then name the former “cause” and the latter “effect”?
In reality, between cause and effect there is always an intermediate link, and it is precisely at this juncture that our observation brings forth a question whose ultimate answer nevertheless eludes our grasp.
For example, we state that fire is the cause of the combustion of wood. But what in fact transpires between fire and the burning of the wood? Heat reaches the wood, its temperature rises, chemical changes take place within it, and finally the process of ignition commences. Thus the existence of fire is one state and the burning of the wood is another; between the two there lies an entire series of transformations. Now the question arises: how did the heat raise the temperature of the wood; in what manner were the chemical changes initiated; and how did one transformation pass into another?
We can seek scientific answers to these questions, yet hidden within every answer lies a fresh question. The process we deem a complete explanation can be broken down into ever smaller stages, and thus between any two stages a new intermediate link emerges. In this way, the more we endeavour to comprehend the gap that separates cause from effect, the more it takes the form of new questions. The real issue is this: even if all these stages be explained, do we thereby comprehend that final and unavoidable relationship which we term cause and effect, or have we merely described in greater detail a sequence of events?
In truth we observe two events: one occurs first and the other thereafter. At times they take place simultaneously, and at times they appear regularly conjoined. We posit a relationship between them and give it the name of causality. Yet for one event to precede another, or to be repeatedly associated with it, is not in and of itself conclusive proof that we have grasped the essential nature of the necessary bond between them.
Upon further reflection it becomes clear that what we designate as a cause is itself the outcome of many other states and events. We say that the seed is the cause of the growth of a tree, but the seed itself came into being from a previous tree, and in the development of that tree soil, water, air, light and countless other factors participated. Where, then, lies the original cause: in the seed, the earth, the water or the light of the sun? The reality is that what we take to be a single cause is often but a part of an extensive chain of interrelated factors. For the sake of intellectual convenience we assign to one stage in this chain the title of cause and to another that of effect.
Here another question is born: if behind every cause there is a prior cause, and every effect in turn becomes linked with some future event, where does this succession end? Is there a first cause behind which no other cause stands? And, if so, how did that cause itself come into existence? Thus the notion of cause and effect draws us into a conceptual circle in which every answer contains within itself the potential for a new question.
It may be that our fundamental error is this: we divide the continuous flow of the cosmos into discrete events for the sake of our own mental convenience. We label one state the cause and the subsequent state the result, whereas it may well be that the two are merely different stages of a single ongoing process. Change is incessant within the universe; one state is transformed into another, and events remain interconnected. In order to comprehend this continuity we express it in the language of cause and effect.
This does not mean that no real connection exists between events, nor that the significance of scientific knowledge is thereby diminished. Science elucidates these connections and the intermediate stages, measures them, and on their basis predicts future events. Yet to predict accurately that one event will follow another and to understand fully the final philosophical bond between them are two distinct matters. To know the order of events is not synonymous with knowing their ultimate reality.
Perhaps we ought to acknowledge that while we are able to observe the sequence, regularity and interrelations of events in the universe, it is not necessary that we attain to every intermediate link and its ultimate reality. By means of the names “cause” and “effect” we arrange events in a certain order, yet it may be that this arrangement reflects our own mode of understanding more than it does absolute reality.
In the end the question is not why one event occurred after another, but whether to know this order suffices for knowing the real and final bond between them. The greatest deception in the concept of causality may well be that, having understood the sequence of events, we regarded that understanding, without penetrating the intermediate links and their ultimate reality, as complete knowledge.