The Dignity of Scholars in Discourse
The genuineness of a person is not tested when he is seated among those of like-minded views and every listener nods approvingly at his speech; his true identity is uncovered when he is faced with someone whose opinion diverges from his own. A man of dignity adorns his disagreement with proof, whereas a man of paltry spirit pollutes it with abuse. One attacks an opponent’s idea, the other targets his person. One unsheathes the sword of reasoning; the other lets fly the arrows of his tongue to conceal his inadequacy.
It has been said that the noble contend with hand and blade, while the ignoble contend with tongue and curse. Yet the rank of the people of learning ought to be loftier still: they have need neither of hand and blade nor of curse. Their weapon is evidence, their ornament forbearance, their strength knowledge and their victory character.
Our discourse here is not about the general public but about ʿulamāʾ and mashāyikh—those whose heads are crowned with turbans, whose hands hold books, and whose tongues repeat qāla Allah and qāla al-rasūl. One would have expected that in their gatherings springs of knowledge would flow, lamps of wisdom would be lit and, despite differences of opinion, mutual respect would remain intact. Yet, when one observes certain assemblies, it becomes clear that everyone possesses books, but the book of manners placed among them has never been opened!
Hardly have a few scholars sat together when the name of an absent scholar is mentioned, and then—what follows! A jibe at some muftī’s fatwā, an impersonation of a khaṭīb’s tone, a comment on a shaykh’s dress, a mockery of a lecturer’s style. If even a tenth of the meticulous attention paid to analysing someone’s gait, bearing and speech were devoted to investigating a scholarly problem, several volumes of learning and literature might well be compiled!
There is backbiting, ridicule, belittling and derision—yet rest assured, all of this proceeds under the banner of scholarly taste! It is as though sin has now acquired certification, and foul speech, within the vocabulary of the learned, has attained the rank of an independent art. Sermonising is for others, and the obligation of good manners, it seems, is likewise reserved for others!
There was a time when the ruling on images was discussed among these very scholars with utmost seriousness. They avoided photography and issued verdicts against it. At the very least, their faces did not appear so frequently on public screens. The times changed, cameras became commonplace, YouTube set out its stall, and many of those for whom the matter of images had once been non-negotiable began to appear before the lens. Some revised their earlier stance, some adopted a new interpretation, some appealed to necessity and others to expediency.
All such scholarly discussions have their place, and a person is entitled to review his position. Yet one question remains: once the ruling on images was reconsidered, were the rulings concerning the tongue also altered? Did the moment one appeared before the camera the prohibition of backbiting, ridicule and belittling also disappear?
Now on YouTube we witness gatherings in which one scholar sits to “take account” of another. A clip of someone’s lecture is cut, a sentence is torn from its context and made into a spectacle, an accent is mimicked, and instead of endeavouring to understand an academic view the man himself is mocked. The titles announce as though some grand scholarly duel is about to take place, but step inside and it turns out that two gentlemen are occupied in ripping up one another’s honour.
The view-count rises, applause fills the comments, admiration is exchanged among friends, and the next day preparations begin for a new contest. One cannot tell whether religion is being served or YouTube’s business model! Common jesters perform for a fee; here, at times, that very performance is given the name of religious service. The sole difference is that there people purchase a ticket for the spectacle, whereas here viewers open the video in the hope of reward!
Nor is this spectacle confined to YouTube. The very same scholarly exercise is carried out at tea-house tables and in private gatherings. The reputation of an absent scholar is being minced while those present sprinkle scholarly salt and pepper over it. The only difference is that on YouTube the audience numbers in thousands, while in the tea-house there are merely a few companions. The sin of backbiting, however, is unaffected by the size of the audience.
The question is this: those very tongues from which the public hear exhortations to avoid backbiting and to honour others—do their own gatherings meet that standard? The Qurʾān forbade mockery, likened backbiting to eating the flesh of one’s dead brother, and prevented the believers from belittling one another. These injunctions are not reserved for any particular class. Whether learned or lay, shaykh or disciple, muftī or khaṭīb, all stand before the same moral scales. Indeed, the greater one’s knowledge, the heavier one’s accountability.
The purpose of knowledge is not merely to amass information but to kindle light within the human being. If the reading of books has not softened the tongue, if the subtleties of fiqh have not broadened the temperament, if the lessons of ḥadīth have not nurtured mercy and humility in the heart, then wherein has that knowledge left its mark? At times a person shoulders such a burden of books that his own humility is crushed beneath it. The references are innumerable, yet forbearance is absent; the tongue is a flood of proofs, but in the heart there is not a single drop of goodwill for one’s brother.
To refute a scholar is an act of scholarly honesty; to humiliate him is moral bankruptcy. To critique a muftī’s fatwā is an academic right; to hurl jibes at his person is tastelessness. If a scholar has uttered something erroneous, clarify his mistake and rebut his argument with evidence. But by aping his voice, imitating his facial expressions and coining jokes upon his name, whose cause are you really serving? That of truth, that of knowledge, or that of the rebellious self?
A strange method of “reform” has been invented: if you wish to rectify someone, first expose him before the whole world, and then proclaim that your only aim was reform. The predecessors taught that advice should be veiled, sincere and wise; now some have given the name of reform even to tearing down the veil!
The reality is that by lowering one’s opponent one does not become elevated. By belittling a scholar one does not increase one’s own scholarly standing. By enumerating another’s faults one’s own are not concealed. And by making ten videos against someone a person does not become ten times more learned; only self-admiration may multiply.
The creation of Allah is already wearied by hatred, enmity, taunts and verbal aggression. It needs not further wounds from the gatherings of scholars but balm; not the spectacle of debates but the light of knowledge; not tales of one another’s disgrace but lessons in self-reformation. The people of learning must look into their own sleeves. Placing a turban on the head does not make a man worthy of that turban; for that, inner capacity is required. Sitting upon the minbar does not make a man worthy of the minbar; for that, character is needed. And amassing millions of viewers on YouTube does not make anyone a scholar; for that, piety of speech and fear of Allah within the heart are essential.
History will not ask how many debates you won, how many opponents you silenced, or how many of your videos went viral; history will also ask: how much did your knowledge add to your character? How many hearts were safe from your tongue? How many people received good from your gatherings? And how much did you safeguard the honour and dignity of your fellow scholars?
A noble person continues to honour his opponent even while believing his stance to be mistaken. He refutes the argument, not the individual. Baseness, by contrast, is that when a person lacks proof he resorts to abuse, when he is deficient in knowledge he takes mockery as a weapon, and when his character is low he targets the dignity of others.
I beg, with folded hands, of the people of learning: adorn your disagreements with knowledge, make your tongue a mirror of your character, and populate your gatherings with mention of good rather than with backbiting and ridicule. Before defeating your opponents, defeat your own nafs.
The tongue from which qāla Allah and qāla al-rasūl are uttered should not demean any Muslim. Otherwise, there is the fear that while pearls of knowledge adorn the tongue, pebbles of backbiting litter the lap of one’s conduct; that there is a turban upon the head but constriction in the heart; that admonition lies upon the lips but abuse in the assemblies; and that the title “scholar” precedes the name while the conduct injures the very honour of knowledge.
For the noble contend with hand and blade, the ignoble with tongue and insult; but the splendour of the people of learning is that they spread light through evidence, win hearts through forbearance and prove the grandeur of knowledge through their character.
May Allah grant the people of learning, together with their knowledge, its due reverence; together with their turban, its dignity; and together with their tongue, the awareness of guarding it. Āmīn.